CDH/VICAR expresses its deep concern over the posting, by UNHCR and the Tanzanian authorities, of a new list at Nyarugusu camp identifying Burundian refugees designated for return to Burundi.
According
to testimonies collected by our organization, those concerned include refugees
transferred from Nduta camp to Nyarugusu, as well as refugees who were already
living in Nyarugusu. These individuals had been brought together for a review
of their cases, presented as a process intended to determine the next steps
regarding their situation, including return to Burundi or possible resettlement
in a third country.
Repeated
warnings about irregularities
CDH/VICAR
recalls that it has repeatedly raised concerns about reported irregularities in
this process and the lack of transparency surrounding case reviews.
According
to information received, individuals with close ties to certain local UNHCR
staff members or Tanzanian local authorities allegedly receive preferential
treatment. Refugees accused by other refugees of mistreatment and political
intimidation in support of the Burundian government are also reportedly among
those receiving preferential access to certain assistance or protection
measures.
These
allegations require an independent and impartial investigation. Decisions
concerning refugee protection must be based on individual needs, the risks faced
and transparent criteria, without favoritism or personal influence.
People
still in need of protection reportedly designated for return
CDH/VICAR
recalls that, during the initial selection process, some refugees whose fears
of return persisted had already left Tanzania to seek refuge in other countries
after seeing their names on lists of people designated for return to Burundi.
Our
organization fears that those appearing on the new list may face the same fate.
According to information received, some cannot safely return to Burundi, given
their personal circumstances, their profiles and the grounds on which they were
granted protection.
The
case review process must not become a mechanism that forces people still in
need of protection to choose between a dangerous return and fleeing once again
to another country.
CDH/VICAR
recalls that UNHCR describes voluntary repatriation as a decision based on a
free and informed choice, allowing refugees to return in safety and dignity.
In
light of this situation, CDH/VICAR calls on:
1. The Tanzanian government and UNHCR to suspend any contested return
measures affecting individuals on this list, pending an individual, impartial
and thorough assessment of their protection needs.
2. UNHCR to clarify the objectives of the review, the
criteria applied and the consequences of the decisions taken, clearly
distinguishing between international protection, voluntary repatriation and
assessment for possible resettlement.
3. The relevant UNHCR bodies and the
Tanzanian authorities
to launch an independent investigation into allegations of favoritism,
conflicts of interest and abuse, while protecting complainants and witnesses
against retaliation.
4. The Tanzanian authorities to guarantee the safety of, and
access to assistance for, refugees who contest their inclusion on the lists,
without intimidation or pressure intended to secure their departure.
5. The international community and
resettlement countries to expand protection opportunities and durable solutions for people who
cannot return safely, based on their needs and without discrimination.
CDH/VICAR
calls on UNHCR and the Tanzanian government to respond transparently to the
concerns raised and to place the protection of individuals at the center of
every decision.
No
administrative list should replace an individual assessment of risks or be used
to force the return of anyone whose need for protection persists.